Extreme Complexity
This is the steering wheel from a 2004 Ferrari F1 car as featured in the Flickr pages of Ed over at Influx Insights. Speaks volumes about what is wrong with F1.
« March 2007 | Main | May 2007 »
This is the steering wheel from a 2004 Ferrari F1 car as featured in the Flickr pages of Ed over at Influx Insights. Speaks volumes about what is wrong with F1.
The Register (a legendary geek news site) have found themselves in possession of some unintentionally funny pen portraits which have allegedly been prepared for Phones4U.
Firstly, is it just me or did those photos get sourced from the pages of MySpace and Flickr?
Secondly, am I alone in suspecting that some of the descriptions of the segments might represent a quite spectacular leap beyond the facts garnered from their analysis? (e.g. The Flashing Blades who "enjoy taking risks and the odd street fight")
Whilst I'm all for adding colour to pen portraits these are probably stretching the data and consumer observations a bit too far in the name of making them more interesting.
Based on the fact that the report contains credit rating information about each of the segments I imagine it came from a direct marketing consultancy.
Somehow I managed to miss the arrival of the stunning Solarshuttle on the Serpentine at Hyde Park last summer. Luckily it's still there.
Zoho, the Indian software company who have released an impressive suite of web-based work productivity applications in direct competition with Microsoft's Office, have just added yet another free application to their offering: a simple online polling tool.
"With Zoho Polls, you can create online polls (public / private) and share with your friends and colleagues to get their opinion. You can create a poll to either vote or to rate a set of options. Create a voting poll when the user needs to select one option from a set of items."
On the one hand applications like this are obviously just a bit of fun and provide no threat to the established market research industry. However, on the other hand, as companies and individuals continue to find cheaper and faster ways to collect survey information the value of the premium that is paid for professional research is being eroded.
I'm convinced that unless the industry can provide a simple and easily understood proxy for sample quality then the uninformed majority will eventually believe that a poll collected for free on a website using software like Zoho is just as valid as one collected by MORI, TNS or GFK/NOP.
I'd argue that it is already the case that most members of the public have been trained by the media to focus on sample size as the only criteria for judging sample quality. The concept of sampling error is ignored by all but the best publications.
The New York TImes is one of the few publications that thankfully continue to insist on reporting sampling error and providing commentary on survey quality. Take a look at this extract from their opinion poll style guide:
Articles about the findings of a public opinion poll should name the person or group who conducted it, name the sponsor and, if necessary, explain the sponsor’s interest in the subject of the poll. The article should also give the number of people surveyed, the dates of the survey and the procedures used (whether interviews were conducted by mail, by telephone or in person). If the poll studied some group other than the general population — registered voters, say, or married adults — the report should say how the respondents were chosen.
The article should give the probable margin of sampling error for a sample of the size used in the poll, and to aid comprehension it should be explained in a sentence like this: The margin of sampling error for a sample of this size is plus or minus five percentage points, so differences of less than that amount are statistically insignificant. Both the poll’s findings and the margin of error should be rounded to the nearest whole percentage point because results rendered to the tenth of a point suggest an impossible degree of precision.
The terms opinion poll, poll, survey, opinion sample and cross section should be limited to scientific soundings of opinion. They should not be applied to roundups of comment or interviews of people in the street. Indeed, extensive articles of that kind should include a cautionary note that the interviews are not a scientific sampling and that only limited conclusions can be drawn from them.
If only the British press still acted in this way.
Some light relief ... a classic Whose Line is it Anyway? Sound Effects skit ...
April 30th marks Tax Freedom day in the United States, the date when the average American stops working for the government and starts working for themselves.
According to the Adam Smith Institute we don't get ours in the UK until 1st June!
Tax
Freedom Day is calculated by taking the UK's net national income and
calculating how much of that is taken away in taxes. These taxes
include not just income tax, but VAT, inheritance tax, stamp duty, car
and fuel taxes, excise taxes on alcohol and cigarettes, taxes on
companies and employment, and many more. For technical stuff about how
Tax Freedom Day is calculated click here.
Tax Freedom Day varies around the country for a description of why and how much, click here.
Ah well, we still get better holidays.
It's been 18 months since we last had a proper holiday. It was a truly great holiday though.
My caffeine consumption is now at an all time high but thankfully we go away again this Friday.
So glad I have a British holiday allowance and not an American one. I really don't know how people manage on 10 days plus Bank Holidays.
Often gazed at Syon House from across the river at Kew but had never been before. Still didn't make it into the house this time but the grounds were wonderful. We'll be back.
As we now we appear to have finally emerged from the British winter I'll be getting my camera out
a little more often. Not a fan of artificial light y'see.
The Cadbury's Creme Egg is not what it once was:
From Conan. Video on YouTube here. 100,000 views and rising. Maybe Cadbury's should have come up with a better answer than "The size hasn't changed - you've just grown up!".
CNET reports on an interesting if extremely low-tech attempt by a company called SideTrack Technologies to install ads in tube tunnels. Imagine a zoetrope in a straight line and you get the idea.
From CNET: "More and more rail systems are installing advertisements in tunnels. Ads from Canada's SideTrack Technologies are based on motion picture technology, so that riders see a "movie" of a long chain of still images as their train goes by. In order to install the still images for the ads, workers must move swiftly, as they can only work when the subway systems are nonoperational, usually at night. SideTrack will soon launch new digital ads in subway tunnels that allow for multiple ad campaigns to run without having to send workers into tunnels to change out still images."
More images and video on the SideTrack site here.
Gordon Torr: Managing Creative People: Lessons for Leadership in the Ideas Economy
I hope Gordon didn't choose that subtitle. It seems below him somehow. Grubby even. His book is, he insists, the first attempt to fully explore how to get the best out of creative people. I'm currently half way through and loving every bit of it. More soon. (****)
Randall Rothenberg: Where the Suckers Moon: The Life and Death of an Advertising Campaign
Rothenberg is a long time NYT journalist who went on to be editor of Ad Age and is now president and CEO of the Interactive Advertising Bureau. Where the Suckers Moon is an implausibly detailed account of the pitch and subsequent development of an ad campaign for Subaru USA. The book ends with Wieden's Subaru ads being voted dead last by consumers on Superbowl Sunday in 1993. It's quite a ride. (*****)
Joshua Ferris: Then We Came to the End
The rythyms of life in a Chicago ad agency during a recession. The writing is a bit too staccato for my liking and the characters are all long gone before you can get to know them. Nonetheless, it is about as close to home as you can get. (***)
Joe Moran: Queuing for Beginners: The Story of Daily Life from Breakfast to Bedtime
More homespun ethnography in the vein of Kate Fox's 'Watching the English'. Makes you think and there is even some gold hidden between the platitides. (****)
Nick Davies: Flat Earth News: An Award-winning Reporter Exposes Falsehood, Distortion and Propaganda in the Global Media
Davies finds his colleagues in the media guilty of systematically recycling press releases and news agency output without checking the facts or seeking to find the truth. Shame he doesn't even attempt to seek a solution. (****)
Sam Delaney: Get Smashed!: The Story of the Men Who Made the Adverts That Changed Our Lives
Enjoyable romp through the history of (mostly British) advertising containing some (possibly apocryphal) tales from those that lived through it. (*****)
Mark Tungate: Adland: A Global History of Advertising
Tungate manages to make the history of advertising boring. Quite an achievement. (**)
Robert Johansen: Get There Early
The Institute for the Future's president Bob Johansen gives us the benefit of his 30 years as a trends forecaster and futurist. (***)
Joe Moran: Queuing for Beginners: The Story of Daily Life from Breakfast to Bedtime
Watching the English revisited. Joe Moran digs into the Mass Observation archive (and a lot more besides) to tell the story of how everyday British habits have changed over the last century. (****)
Oona Strathern: A Brief History of the Future; How Visionary Thinkers Changed the World and Tomorrow's Trends Are 'Made' and Marketed
A worthy attempt at pulling together the history of futurists and trendspotters. Nice companion to 'Where's my Jetpack?' (****)
Jim Taylor & Steve Hatch: Rigorous Magic: Communication Ideas and Their Application
A valiant but ultimately flawed attempt to codify and assess the value of different types of communications ideas. The typology they have created is useful but they fall down when it comes to providing workable definitions (e.g. between an 'emotional platform' and a 'brand idea'). Furthermore, being media men they are predictably in thrall of those kinds of ideas that media agencies can control ('activation' and 'symbiotic' ideas), less enthusiastic about 'brand' ideas and brazenly critical of the value of 'advertising' ideas. (**)
Stuart Maconie: Pies and Prejudice: In Search of the North
Imagine if Pevsner was written by Nick Hornby. Maconie fights his demons about living in the South of England by going back home to the North. Supposendly a travel book, this is Maconie's humorous and informative take on the North-South divide. (***)
Mark Earls: Herd: How to Change Mass Behaviour by Harnessing Our True Nature
Mark Earls, the professional contrarian and erstwhile Head of Planning at Ogilvy London has developed his ideas about herd thinking into a book for all to see. (****)
Dick Taverne: The March of Unreason: Science, Democracy, and the New Fundamentalism
If you like Ben Goldacre's Bad Science column in The Guardian then you will enjoy this. I don't agree with all of it but then that's part of the point. (***)
Andrew Marr: My Trade: A Short History of British Journalism
Andrew Marr writes his autobiography under the guise of authoring an insider perspective on the world of news journalism. Fascinating and written with a light touch. Not as ambitious as it might have been but riveting nonetheless. (****)